New Haven, IN

Find the Best Contractors in New Haven

Discover top-rated home service professionals in New Haven, Indiana. Browse 115 verified contractors for roofing, HVAC, plumbing, and more.

115

Contractors

4.5

Avg. Rating

🏠Get Competitive Quotes from Manually Vetted Contractors

Find the Right Contractor in New Haven

Answer a few quick questions and we'll help you find the contractor that fits your needs, location, and availability.

New Haven, IN

Step 1 of 2

What service are you looking for?

100% FreeNo CommitmentTop-Rated Contractors

Top Contractors in New Haven, IN

Showing 1-20 of 115 contractors

Landscaping
Hours
AG Interiors LLC

AG Interiors LLC

New Haven, IN

5(1 reviews)

"They did a wonderful job painting our home, and remodeling our bathroom!"

PaintingDrywall
Hours
Visit Website
Flores Roofing & Remodel

Flores Roofing & Remodel

14019 Old 24 E Rd, New Haven, IN 46774

5(16 reviews)

"He was super helpful…got the job done quick…"

RoofingSidingGuttersKitchen Remodel+4 more
Hours
Visit Website
J J Mechanical LLC

J J Mechanical LLC

New Haven, IN

5
Plumbing
Hours
Visit Website
Signature System Built Homes Inc.

Signature System Built Homes Inc.

2846 Turnpointe Blvd, New Haven, IN 46774

5(2 reviews)
Home BuilderGeneral Contracting
Hours
Marr Contracting LLC

Marr Contracting LLC

New Haven, IN

5(2 reviews)

"... came out and fixed a major problem that I had with my contractors."

Decks & PatiosGeneral Contracting
Hours
Visit Website
Brunson Property Services

Brunson Property Services

909 Chamberlin Ct, New Haven, IN 46774

5
Tree Services
Hours
Visit Website

"Great communication, prices and results!"

GuttersLandscapingTree Services
Hours
Visit Website
BOGGS PRO CUTS

BOGGS PRO CUTS

New Haven, IN

5(5 reviews)
GuttersTree ServicesLandscaping
Hours
The Generator Authority

The Generator Authority

New Haven, IN

5(8 reviews)

"No only is Gary knowledgeable and a professional."

Electrical
Hours
Visit Website
Kennebec by D.R. Horton

Kennebec by D.R. Horton

5235 Bing Pass, New Haven, IN 46774

5(6 reviews)

"Extremely knowledgeable and quick to respond to questions."

Home Builder
Hours
Visit Website
Next Level Services

Next Level Services

175 N Rufus St, New Haven, IN 46774

5(2 reviews)

"OUTSTANDING!"

Foundation RepairConcrete
Hours
Visit Website
T & C Concrete

T & C Concrete

17206 Tillman Rd, Monroeville, IN 46773

5(2 reviews)

"Not only are they very responsive & quick to complete a job;"

Concrete
Hours
Riverwalk Villas by D.R. Horton

Riverwalk Villas by D.R. Horton

953 Miller Wds Wy, New Haven, IN 46774

5(8 reviews)

"Very helpful with the information needed for our clients"

Home Builder
Hours
Visit Website
Kennebec Paired Villas by D.R. Horton

Kennebec Paired Villas by D.R. Horton

10219 Ashby Trail, New Haven, IN 46674

5(2 reviews)

"Justin did a great job showing the villa!"

Home Builder
Hours
Visit Website
Riverwalk by D.R. Horton

Riverwalk by D.R. Horton

953 Miller Wds Wy, New Haven, IN 46774

5(21 reviews)

"He’s honest, reliable and his communication is impeccable!"

Home Builder
Hours
Visit Website
Trek Painting & Pressure Washing

Trek Painting & Pressure Washing

New Haven, IN

5(1 reviews)
Painting
Hours
Matt Klotz Heating Plumbing

Matt Klotz Heating Plumbing

161 West St, New Haven, IN 46774

5(3 reviews)
PlumbingHVAC
Hours
Brown's Magical Touch

Brown's Magical Touch

New Haven, IN

5(1 reviews)
PaintingDrywall
Hours
Outback Concrete Coatings

Outback Concrete Coatings

New Haven, IN

5(20 reviews)

"Excellent quality, timely service, great communication!"

PaintingConcrete
Hours
Visit Website
πŸ†

Top Rated Contractors 2026

New Haven, IN

Every contractor shown for New Haven, Indiana is listed with the rating and review count from its public Google Business Profile, so you can compare local professionals on the same basis. Businesses marked as claimed have confirmed their own details, which is not the same as a licence or insurance check. Confirm licensing and insurance directly, then request at least three written estimates before you hire in New Haven.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about finding contractors in New Haven

Prices in New Haven depend on the trade, the size and complexity of the job, and the materials you choose. Small repairs often start in the low hundreds of dollars, while full replacements such as a roof, HVAC system, or kitchen can run from several thousand dollars upward. Request at least three written estimates for the same scope so you can compare local pricing fairly.

Start with the listings on this page, then confirm the licence directly with the licensing board that covers Indiana. Requirements vary by trade: some states license general contractors, while others license only electrical, plumbing, and HVAC work. Ask for the licence number and verify it yourself before signing anything.

Most listings in New Haven are aggregated from public business data, including the Google Business Profile rating and review count shown on each page, and are not individually inspected by us. A listing marked as claimed simply means the owner has confirmed control of the business record; it is not a licence or insurance check. Always verify licensing, insurance, and references before you hire.

Costs in Indiana depend heavily on the trade and the project. Labour rates vary by region, licensed trades such as electrical and plumbing usually cost more per hour than general labour, and emergency or after-hours work carries a premium. Statewide averages are only a starting point; get itemized quotes from local contractors for your exact scope.

Permit rules are set by the local authority that covers New Haven. Structural work, additions, and most electrical, plumbing, HVAC, and roofing replacements require a permit, while some cosmetic work does not. Ask who is pulling the permit and confirm it is issued in the correct name before work starts, because unpermitted work can complicate resale and insurance.

A deposit of roughly 10-30% of the contract price to cover materials is common in New Haven, with the balance tied to milestones in a written contract. Be cautious of anyone demanding full payment up front, large cash-only payments, or payment before the work is scheduled. A written payment schedule protects both sides.

Compare quotes on the same written scope of work, not on the bottom line alone. Check that each quote lists materials and brands, labour, permits, cleanup, and exclusions, and ask how change orders are priced. A bid that is far below the others usually means something has been left out.

A contractor contract in Indiana should state the full scope, materials, total price and payment schedule, estimated start and completion dates, the licence number, how changes will be approved and priced, the warranty, and who handles permits and cleanup. Read it before signing and keep a copy.

Timelines in New Haven vary widely by trade and scope, from a same-day repair to several months for a major remodel. Weather, permit queues, and material lead times all affect the schedule. Ask each contractor for a written timeline and confirm how they handle weather or inspection delays.

Read the Google review excerpts shown on each listing for patterns rather than judging only by the star average. Also check the state or provincial licensing board for complaints, ask the contractor for recent local references, and confirm they carry insurance. A single bad review matters less than a consistent theme.

Pricing in New Haven reflects local labour rates, cost of living, demand, and how far crews have to travel. Dense metro areas and high-cost regions usually run above the state average, while smaller markets can be below it. The only accurate comparison is like-for-like quotes from contractors who work in New Haven.

Document everything in writing first, including photos, dates, and the contract. Ask the contractor to fix the issue under the warranty, and if they refuse, file a complaint with the Indiana licensing board or consumer-protection office. You can also contact us so we can review the listing associated with that business.