Skip to content
ContractorsRanked

How much does a furnace replacement cost in Middle Island, NY?

US national rangeUpdated Prices checked October 20261 source

A furnace replacement costs $2,823 to $6,896 nationally, typical $4,814. We have no documented price index for Middle Island for this job, so this is the US national range from HomeAdvisor, checked October 2026.

US national range, not adjusted for this city

Low
$2,823
Typical
$4,814
High
$6,896

Get furnace replacement quotes in Middle Island

Furnace replacement cost in Middle Island, NY

We have no documented price index for Middle Island for this job, so the table shows the US national range.

Furnace replacement cost in Middle Island, NY
EstimateLowTypicalHighBasisChecked
US national range$2,823$4,814$6,896Per system, installed; typical range of customer-reported jobs (HomeAdvisor)October 2026

Furnace replacement cost by type or size

US national figures in USD, as published by each source.

Furnace replacement cost by type or size
Type or sizePrice (USD)Source
Electric furnace$2,000 to $7,000HomeAdvisor
Gas furnace$3,800 to $10,000HomeAdvisor
Oil furnace$6,750 to $10,000HomeAdvisor

What drives the cost of a furnace replacement

  1. Fuel type

    Electric furnaces cost least to install; oil costs the most.

  2. Efficiency rating

    High-AFUE furnaces cost more up front.

  3. Home size

    Furnaces are sized at roughly 30 to 60 BTUs per square foot.

  4. Climate

    Colder regions need more capacity.

  5. Removal of the old unit

    Removal and disposal typically add $150 to $330.

Permits and what's included in Middle Island

Permit note

Furnace replacement usually needs a mechanical permit, and gas work may need its own. Ask your local building department for the fee.

Rules are set locally; confirm with Middle Island’s building department.

What’s usually included

  • The new furnace
  • Connection to existing ducts, venting and fuel supply
  • Startup and testing

Scopes vary. Get the scope in writing on every quote.

Get furnace replacement quotes in Middle Island

Tell us about the job and we will pass it to local pros. Asking for quotes never changes how we rank anyone.

Two short steps: your name, then how to reach you. Free, and it never changes anyone’s rank.

Top-ranked HVAC contractors in Middle Island

The top 3 of 539 HVAC contractors we rank for Middle Island, NY, by CR Score. Paid placement never changes rank.

  1. #1
    Kintech Heating, Cooling & Plumbing
    CR Score 655.0from 633 Google reviews
  2. #2
    Airborne Heating & Air Conditioning - HVAC Contractor
    CR Score 655.0from 439 Google reviews
  3. #3
    US Air Conditioning & Heating
    CR Score 644.8from 582 Google reviews

See all ranked HVAC contractors in Middle Island

Furnace replacement cost in Middle Island: questions

How much does a furnace replacement cost in Middle Island, NY?

A furnace replacement costs $2,823 to $6,896 nationally, typical $4,814. We have no documented price index for Middle Island for this job, so this is the US national range from HomeAdvisor, checked October 2026.

Do I need a permit for a furnace replacement in Middle Island?

Furnace replacement usually needs a mechanical permit, and gas work may need its own. Ask your local building department for the fee. Rules are set locally, so confirm with Middle Island’s building department.

What affects the cost of a furnace replacement?

Fuel type: electric furnaces cost least to install; oil costs the most. Efficiency rating: high-AFUE furnaces cost more up front. Home size: furnaces are sized at roughly 30 to 60 BTUs per square foot. Climate: colder regions need more capacity.

How many HVAC contractors serve Middle Island?

We rank 539 HVAC contractors for Middle Island, NY by CR Score. Get at least three written quotes for the same scope.

What is usually included in the price?

The new furnace; Connection to existing ducts, venting and fuel supply; Startup and testing. Always get the scope in writing on the quote.

Sources

Checked October 2026. Figures are estimates, not quotes.

  1. HomeAdvisor: Furnace replacement cost · page updated June 17, 2026 · checked October 2026Primary source. Used for: Low, typical and high; prices by fuel; drivers.
These are published estimates, checked October 2026. They are not quotes. Typical range shown: $2,823 to $6,896. Editorial policy

Related pages

More cost guides for Middle Island